CIEE accelerates scientific progress through programs that synthesize current knowledge and develop our future leaders.
The Canadian Institute of Ecology and Evolution / Institut canadien d’écologie et d’évolution (CIEE / ICEE) is a consortium of Canadian universities with the mission of expanding and accelerating scientific discovery on the natural environment and its contributions to our national well being.
The CIEE/ICEE extracts significant added value from Canada’s research investment through projects that mine new insights from the wealth of existing data. Its training programs aim to prepare the generation of scientists who will be called upon to address our most vexing environmental problems.
New 2014 Scientific Programs!
We are pleased to report that three new Thematic Working group proposals have been selected for funding by CIEE, including:
1. “Canada’s phylogenetic diversity in a changing world”. Main applicants: Dr. Jana Vamosi and Dr. Jeremy Kerr. Awarded Grant $12,200 CAD;
2. “The terra incognita of community ecology: understanding continental-scale variation of ecological networks”. Main applicants: Dr. Timothée Poisot, Pr. Dominique Gravel and Dr. Daniel Stouffer. Awarded Grant: $14,400 CAD, and;
3. “Forecasting groundfish biodiversity change in the Newfoundland shelf”. Main applicants: Dr. Andrew Gonzalez, Dr. Fred Guichard, MSc. Patrick Thompson, and MSc. Eric Pedersen. Awarded Grant: $6,120 CAD.
Congratulations to all the participants and please see our Attached Newsletter for further details on each proposal!
We had a remarkable response to our Call for Proposals and received ten competitive applications ranging from across the entire country. Despite the timing of the Call in mid-summer, the quality of applications was exceptional!
The selection process was careful and comprehensive with each proposal receiving 5-6 independent reviews. We take this opportunity to extend especial thanks the members of CIEE’s Scientific Advisory Committee (SAC), including Marc Cadotte (U. Toronto), Jeffrey Hutchings (Dalhousie Univ), Sue Bertram (Carleton Univ.), Dennis Murray (Trent Univ.), Denis Réale (UQAM) and Bradley Anholt (U. Victoria) for their outstanding work in the review process.
In general, scientific excellence and likelihood of success were the main general criteria for evaluation, although consideration was also made for the degree to which proposals helped CIEE demonstrate broader benefits to Canada, fiscal responsibility, and benefits to sustaining member organizations. Specifically the criteria for evaluations were:
1. Project rationale: scientific significance of the questions (novel insights?), likelihood to advance understanding in Ecology, Evolution or Environmental issues, evidence of novel synthesis, evidence of benefit to Canadian environmental and economic well being
2. Project description: clarity of objectives, outcomes, work plan, meeting schedule.
3. Expertise of applicants and participants (from CVs/NSERC forms). This evaluation also evaluated evidence of participant diversity (institution, career stage, gender).
4. Potential for defined scientific products, including refereed publications.
5. Budget adequacy and feasibility (complete estimates and coherent justification).
Each reviewer provided written summaries of the relative merits of each proposal, and were asked to rank all proposals to each criterion on the same absolute scale (1-10). Relative rankings were synthesized to achieve a final recommendation for funding. After awarded applicants effectively responded to reviewers’ feedbacks and addressed critical comments from the CIEE Director and Assistant Director, Funding Agreements between parts (CIEE and grantees) were developed. These formal agreements extensively describe rights and responsibilities by the parts, allowing a clear and organized use and control of funding.
We encourage you to participate in future CIEE programs. In this regard, we anticipate a new Call for Proposals to be issued during Fall of 2014.